Massachusetts Moderators Presidents
| 1. | 1956-1958 | George Batchelder | Amesbury | |
| 2. | 1958-1960 | Robert Bodfish | Longmeadow | |
| 3. | 1960-1961 | Rudolph King | Millis | |
| 4. | 1961-1963 | Raymond Fessenden | Athol | |
| 5. | 1963-1965 | Richard B. Johnson | Swampscott | |
| 6. | 1965-1967 | Benjamin A. Trustman | Brookline | |
| 7. | 1967-1968 | Roger F. Langley | Barre | |
| 8. | 1969-1971 | Harrison Chadwick | Winchester | |
| 9. | 1971-1972 | Philip T. Jones | Weymouth | |
| 10. | 1972-1974 | Egbert S. Newbury | Concord | |
| 11. | 1974-1976 | Joseph Harrington, Jr. | Wenham | |
| 12. | 1976-1977 | Charles L. Kirkpatrick | South Hadley | |
| 13. | 1977-1978 | Peter L. McDowell | Dennis | |
| 14. | 1978-1979 | Robert E. Kubicek | East Longmeadow | |
| 15. | 1979-1980 | Alan S. Novick | North Dartmouth | |
| 16. | 1980-1981 | Robert S. Gosselin | Groton | |
| 17. | 1981-1982 | Maren Feil | Tisbury | |
| 18. | 1982-1983 | George W. Burnham | Upton | |
| 19. | 1983-1984 | Donald B. Hyde, Jr. | Stow | |
| 20. | 1984-1985 | Neil M. Brandt | Sturbridge | |
| 21. | 1985-1986 | Trescott T. Abele | Pepperell | |
| 22. | 1986-1987 | C. Parker Swann III | Northborough | |
| 23. | 1987-1988 | Richard L. Allen | Framingham | |
| 24. | 1988-1989 | Douglas D. Nichols | Ludlow | |
| 25. | 1989-1990 | Leonard M. Wilson | Sherborn | |
| 26. | 1990-1991 | Norman Nathan | Middleton | |
| 27. | 1991-1992 | Donald MacKenzie | Acton | |
| 28. | 1992-1993 | John M. Russell, Jr. | Hull | |
| 29. | 1993-1994 | Elisabeth J. Noyes | Shirley | |
| 30. | 1994-1995 | Ralph C. Copeland | Medfield | |
| 31. | 1995-1996 | Harry S. Terkanian | Wellfleet | |
| 32. | 1996-1997 | Joseph Harrington III | Westborough | |
| 33. | 1997-1998 | Margery M. Battin | Lexington | |
| 34. | 1998-1999 | Henry L. Hall, Jr. | Belmont | |
| 35. | 1999-2000 | Klaus Kubierschky | North Reading | |
| 36. | 2000-2001 | Richard L. Nickless | Petersham | |
| 37. | 2001-2002 | Ellen S. Harde | Westford | |
| 38. | 2002-2003 | Harrison L. Gregg | Amherst | |
| 39. | 2003-2004 | Maureen M. Sullivan | Billerica | |
| 40. | 2004-2005 | Charles A. Salisbury | North Andover | |
| 41. | 2005-2006 | Alan E. Foulds | Reading | |
| 42. | 2006-2007 | Paul E. Connolly | Natick | |
| 43. | 2007-2008 | Betsey J. Anderson | Bedford | |
| 44. | 2008-2009 | Edward N. Perry | Concord | |
| 45. | 2009-2010 | Frederick A. George | Northborough | |
| 46. | 2010-2011 | Deborah Medders | Tisbury | |
| 47. | 2011-2012 | Edward (Sandy) Gadsby | Brookline | |
| 48. | 2012-2013 | Robert H. Saquet | Mansfield | |
| 49. | 2013-2014 | Harry A. Pape | Princeton | |
| 50. | 2014-2015 | Christopher Brittain | Lee | |
| 51. | 2015-2016 | Deborah J. Brown | Lexington | |
| 52. | 2016-2017 | David C. Loeper | Upton | |
| 53. | 2017-2018 | John D. Leone | Arlington | |
| 54. | 2018-2019 | Christopher G. Mehne | Shrewsbury |